I first published this Cookies and Cream Cheesecake Cupcakes recipe in 2010. Since then, that post has received over a million hits and over 175,000 Pinterest pins and 46,000 “likes” on Stumble Upon.
It was the first post I ever published to go viral, and it was absolutely thrilling. Since then I’ve had posts achieve similar internet attention, but that was the first one and I’ll always remember it!
When I was brainstorming video ideas for April, I quickly realized I absolutely needed to create a video on these cupcakes since they are one of my most popular recipes. This post is now the updated version of that original 2010 post. The original post has over 300 comments, some of which are questions about the recipe and some of which are very entertaining. I think the video answers a lot of questions you may have, as just seeing how something is made gives you so much more confidence to enter the kitchen. At least I think so!
Cookies and Cream Cheesecake Cupcakes Recipe Tips:
The recipe posted below is HALVED from the original recipe here. Having 30 of these cupcakes in my house is way too dangerous. Also, making 30 cupcake requires three muffins tins and I only have 2. Both options are available to you for whichever yield you prefer!
Yes, 275°F is the right temperature. You want to bake these in a cooler oven to avoid having overbaked or cracked cupcakes.
Allow the cupcakes to come to room temperature before chilling in the fridge for at least 4 hours. I like to chill overnight.
I ran out of paper liners in the making of this video, but DEFINITELY use them if you have them. The cupcakes will still turn out without them, but they’re much prettier, easier to transport, and easier to clean with them. I like to use standard white paper cupcake liners so the Oreo on the bottom peeks through like in the top photo.
Bake these for 22 minutes, or until the cheesecake is set. If the batter is still slightly jiggly in the middle, that is fine. Err on the side of underbaking vs. overbaking. However, you may still need to add an extra minute or two of baking time if your oven runs cold.
You can substitute nonfat plain Greek yogurt for the sour cream, but I prefer sour cream. You can also use light cream cheese if you want, again I prefer full-fat.
Since these are made with cream cheese, they need to be stored in the refrigerator. If you plan on bringing them to a party or potluck, that’s fine. Just be aware that they shouldn’t sit at room temperature for an extended period of time.
how would I know if I have over mixed the batter?? 🙁
Hey can you freeze these? I love my cheesecake hard! And if so how many days would they last in the freezer?
We used this recipe in a sous vide at 180F for 90 minutes, and it was perfect!!!
Have you ever made these with DOUBLE Stuff
Oreos … think they’d work as well as regular Oreos? Thanks!
Would it work ok to use foil cupcake liners instead of paper ones? Also, same question for the peanut butter cup cupcakes. Thanks!
I find paper liners work best for these!
do you think i could switch the oreo that you mix in with the batter for snickers? so i’d still be using oreos for the base but would like snickers to be in the actual cheesecake
Yep! That’ll work just fine.
This is the best desert recipe I’ve ever come across. I started making these in 2014 and they are always a huge hit! People think I’m some amazing baker after eating them. Thank you so much for sharing this magical recipe with the world!
I have made these several times and they are a huge hit! If taking them somewhere, I usually “decorate” them with whipped cream and a mini Oreo.
I was thinking of making them for a cookie exchange, but the original size is a bit too big. Any thoughts on whether they can be made with mini Oreos using mini cupcake liners/pans? Thanks!
Do you think you can use the Christmas Oreos for this recipe (cookies and cream cupcakes)?
I’ve made these in two different ovens and both to times they were under baked. Can’t decide what time/ temp is best to cook them. The last batch I made was at 300 degrees for almost 30 minutes and they came out great, although they cracked slightly.
What a cute cupcakes!!!
these were a total hit! my bf loved them! lol LOL
Yay! Happy to hear that 🙂
I noticed that someone before me also asked this question, but I didn’t see the answer. If I want to make this as a cake – say in a 10″ springform pan – what temperature should I bake it at and for how long?
Okay! These are so amazing! I made them exactly like you do and so delicious. Just found you/ your blog and so happy I did. I think your wonderful!
Switched out the Chocolate Oreos for Golden Oreos and added lemon zest and lemon extract instead of vanilla. They were fabulous!
Awesome!! Glad you were able to make the recipe your own 🙂
I’m planning to make this recipe this week. I can’t wait.
Hi, I just made these – they are cooling and look great.. My batter seemed more runny than yours and I got 20 cup cakes. Is that due to overbeating?
When you said do not over mix, what exactly will it do to the batter? How could I over mix by mistake and what would be the out come of I did by accident? Thanks!
How is it that the cup cakes do not stick to the paper lines? I’m worried this would happen. Any issue with that happening ?
If you use high quality liners it should be fine. You can also spray them very lightly with nonstick spray before baking.
Hey my name is Leonard
My School and I are going to a nursing home and we have to prepare a dessert for the people I would like to ask you if it would be alright to use your recipe.
Of course! What a nice thing to do 🙂
I made cupcakes using silken tofu and replacing sour cream with Greek yogurt. I had to bake it for about 30 minutes. Turned out really nice and yummy. Everyone loved it. Big hit!!!!!!
What egg substitute you prefer if I want to make eggless. Usually I use silken Tofu as egg replacer.
I’m not sure, I don’t substitute eggs often. Let us know how the tofu works out if you try it!
I’m going to make these with a chocolate wafer bottom instead of the cookies; they look delicious! For those who are tempted to use low fat cream cheese or sour cream, that is likely why your batter turned out too runny. Cheesecake, to be truly delicious, needs to be made with the recipe using full fat. I figure the calories might be reduced slightly by using crumb crust instead of a whole cookie in each one, but they are probably individually still less calories than a slice of a whole cake. My motto is that I’ll eat something delicious if its worth the calories (and a lot of time the lower fat versions, especially anything with cool whip – yuck), are just not worth it. Have some fresh fruit instead lol. I’d rather have a delicious treat once a month and never mind the calories. My two cents worth …
I made these last night, refrigerated overnight and oh my goodness!!!! They turned out perfect! So good! I want to eat all of them, very delicious and easy recipe. Will make this again and again and again!!
Hi! How long can these cupcake stay out? I want to hand them out at school but I don’t want them to turn to mush before I can get them to my friends.
Can’t wait to try!
When someone writes an paragraph he/she maintains the plan of a user in his/her mind that how a user can understand it.
Thus that’s why this piece of writing is outstdanding. Thanks!
are these the mini oreos or the regular size ones? i ask because all the recipes in this group are made in ‘mini’ muffin cups and this one seems to use regular size oreos which wont fit in a mini muffin pan.
My co-worker made these for an after school meeting…these are awesome!!! Thank you. I will be making these with my daughter. She loves to bake.
Wonderful! Happy baking you two 🙂
These were absolutely wonderful! Very easy and clean to bake, and super delicious! My mixture was a bit runny (compared to the video), but in the end it turned out fine. I think it was because the cream cheese was a bit too soft to start off with. Thank you for the recipe.
This recipe is exactly the same as the cookies and cream cupcake recipe in Martha Stewart’s Cupcakes book. Except yours is half the recipe. I believe the picture you have on your site is the exact same as well. I wonder who came up with the recipe first??
I love this recipe and wanted to share it on a newsletter for SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) charity group… in the hope it brightens up someone else’s day during a difficult time as much as it did mine…is this possible?
Hi Fiona, please feel free to share ANY of my recipes for your newsletter. I would be touched if they might brighten someone’s day during an unimaginably difficult time.
Sadly, these were delicious but utterly underbaked. Not advisable for any toaster-oven users out there…
Can you tell me cooking time if I make mini cupcakes with mini Oreos?
What an amazing recipe! I used regular sized standing cups in muffin tins and yielded 14 pcs. Baked at 140 deg cel for 22 mins and perfecto – no cracks n slightly jiggle. The sour cream adds a nice tangy taste to the cheesecake. Lovely. My new go-to recipe. Thanks for sharing!
How long did it take for you to make this Recipt
Do you have nutrition information per serving? I came up with 11g fat, 21g carbs and 4g protein! Thoughts??
Do you happen to have the nutritional info?
Since I’m not a registered dietician I don’t feel comfortable supplying nutritional info, though there are many recipe calculators that will allow you to find that out for yourself!
These look delicious though my comment is about something else… I noticed that the salt you use is from Costco, there has been a recent recall on Costco sold pepper as a result of possible Samonella contamination
Awesome!! It is attractive at the same time delicious too….Last week I tried carrot cupcake and it was one of the best cake which I ever had..here is the link …
Folks….Just try it out:http://www.clubnoor.com/en/recipe/carrot-cupcake
Just tried making these, they’re baking as I type. I followed the recipe exactly, except I used light soft cheese instead of cream cheese (Google said soft cheese and cream cheese are the same thing). It made incredibly runny mixture, like, completely liquid. I used a sprung ice cream scoop to put the mixture into cupcake cases (which was very messy as it was so runny lol), and 1 whole scoop was far too much for one cupcake case, so I’ve ended up making 18/19 of them. Is there something I’ve done wrong? In your video your batter is way more solid than mine =/
Hello! Made this so many times, it’s too amazing!! I want to bake oreo cheesecake as a whole cake, but this recipe is so good that I reuse to use other recipes. How should I alter the baking time and temperature if I want to bake this as an 8 inch cake?
I followed this recipe to a T. It made 30 cupcakes– not 15.
Tastes amazing though, so no complaints.
Haha, FAIL! Meant to post on the Snickers Cheesecake. That’s what happens when you post a review at almost midnight. Not able to delete so please feel free to do it or stick it in the right place for me. Thanks !
Just one look and I knew this HAD to be our Christmas dessert this year. So here’s my feedback. Followed directions to a t and used what I imagine is a 9″ springform pan. Well, it was scary to see it in the oven because it came up the sides a good inch out of the pan. Had to cook an extra 15 minutes because even though directions said better to under bake than over bake, it was way too undone. 15 extra minutes still left the center a bit wobbly but decided I couldn’t leave it in there more time than that. Once out of the oven and after it cooled, the center was shallower than the middle. Easy fix though. Took a sharp knife and just leveled this baby out. Figured the ganache would make it pretty again. And I was absolutely right! Oh, and did I mention how hard (impossible) it was NOT to scarf down all the extra chunks I cut off? They didn’t stand a chance. Next time, I will probably make half the recipe to end up with a slimmer cake. But once done, it is gorgeous and delicious. Thank you for this recipe.
I made these last night and cooked at the recommended temp. but this morning they seem to be very soft and do not come out of the liner very nicely : ( Can I pop these back into the oven today? I was hoping to bring these to a holiday party this afternoon.
Hi can I use creamed cottage cheese
I’m not sure I’ve never tried that in a cheesecake recipe.
I have not made these yet, but after reading all the comments, I will be making them soon. I stumbled upon this recipe because I was asked if I am the mom who makes the mini oreo cheesecakes. My son’s varsity football team has dinners every week before the next day’s game and the moms provide the desserts. Guess I need to step up my ‘A game’ this week since they are in the playoffs 🙂 Thanks for sharing this.
(never mind I just watched the video!! duh!!
Yum!! Will be making these. They look frosted but I guess not?? Thanks for all your yummy recipes!
Hi Tessa, I just wanted to say thanks for your reply and the Oreo Cheesecake Cupcakes were a super hit! 🙂
These look super cute I want to make these for a charity bake sale at work. How long can they stay out in room temperature? Thanks
They should be fine at room temp for the day! I would refrigerate them until you bring them to the bake sale.
1 pound is how many gram cream cheese?
And 1/2 cup granulated sugar and sour cream in gram please
Heyy what can i subtitue the sour cream with?
Can i change it to yoghurt?
Plain yogurt should work just fine.
I was wondering if I could use Greek yogurt in this recipe instead of sour cream?
The answer to your question is included in the post: “You can substitute nonfat plain Greek yogurt for the sour cream, but I prefer sour cream. You can also use light cream cheese if you want, again I prefer full-fat.”
This recipe, seen on my facebook feed back in 2010, is what brought me to your blog! I’ve been a “religious” reader since 🙂 I can’t count how many times I’ve made these. I lived with guys for part of college and I’m pretty sure I made these babies twice a week that entire summer! They made weekly appearances at physics and chem study groups and were oft-requested by everyone in my life. I made these for my current boyfriend of over 2 years a few weeks into our relationship and I am convinced these are the reason he started dating me!! So what I’m trying to say is thank you for this gorgeous, yummy recipe and all the ones I’ve gotten from you since! 😀
I can see why this is so popular! Totally delicious!